Churchville's St. John's Anglican Church was closely connected with Trinity Anglican Church in Streetsville and always shared clergy.
When St. John's closed, all of the liturgical furnishings, records and church ornaments were relocated to Streetsville.

1870 Isaac Middleton, B.A.
1870-1879 William  Stephen Westney, B.A., M.A., B.D. (also principal of Streetsville High School)
1879-1880 Charles Benson Dundas, B.A., M.A.
1881-1885 John Alexander Hanna, B.A.
1885-1889 Joseph Fletcher, B.A., M.A.
1890-1893 Otho Talbot Bourdois Croft
1892-1893     Charles Samuel Gustavus Lutz, MD
1893-1903 John Hughes Jones
1903-1909 Charles Herbert Rich (also Grand Chaplain of Grand Lodge of Canada in the Province of Ontario, AF & AM)
1910-1911 James Hale Talbot
1912-1918 Thomas Oliver Curliss
1918-1919 Edward Forrester Hockley